This Web Accessibility icon serves as a link to download eSSENTIAL Accessibility assistive technology software for individuals with physical disabilities.

FEATURES













The Drama of Being Bullied at Work
By Zayda Rivera - Nov 20, 2008
Photo

Keywords: workplace diversity, peer relationships, job tips, bullying

 

If you read Workplace Bullying: Why Women Are Affected More, you discovered key information about why women bully women more often in the workplace than men do. But the underlying message was that bullying, across the lines of gender, culture, religion and sexual orientation, is wrong--period.

 

Stress affects the health of 45 percent of bullied targets, according to a survey conducted by the Workplace Bullying Institute (WBI) and Zogby International. That stress is then carried home with the victim and can potentially cause dissonance with family and friends.

 

"[Bullying] crosses the line when it causes someone to have their health harmed, either their mental health or their emotional health or their physical health," Dr. Gary Namie of the Workplace Bullying Institute says in a television interview. "It's health-harming mistreatment, and it's not just tough management, either. That's mythical. A bullying boss is one who disproportionately dumps everything on one or two people that they've targeted for the mistreatment."

 

About 37 percent of American workers, or 54 million people, have been bullied at work at one point or another, according to the survey. Of the Latinos polled, 52 percent said they'd been bullied. Forty-six percent of Blacks polled said they had been bullied. Interestingly, there are higher occurrences of depression and domestic violence among these two groups as well.

 

Depression is the leading mental-health problem among Latino immigrants, according to the book Depression in Latinos by Sergio A. Aguilar-Gaxiola and Thomas P. Gullotta. It is difficult to give a specific percentage of how many Black people are affected because 63 percent view depression as a "personal weakness," according to the Congressional Black Caucus Foundation, and thus do not seek treatment.

 

According to WBI, mistreatment at work can directly cause domestic violence.

 

Here are some ways being bullied at work can negatively affect domestic stability and tranquility:

 

Taking it out on the wrong person

Often, targets of workplace bullying don't feel confident in reporting a problem to the human-resources department for fear of backlash or being labeled as a "complainer" or "whiner."

 

"Most [people in human resources] like to blow it off and discount it," Namie says.

 

So instead of risking losing their job, people hold the stresses of being bullied at work until they get home. Then they lash out at those they love. According to the WBI, the enemy is the bully, but family members pay the price for the target's inability or unwillingness to fight back at work.

 

Nonverbal messages

Some people try to keep bullying at work to themselves, but loved ones can often spot nonverbal messages. The WBI gives the examples of sleep disruption (ranked No. 2 for health consequences for bullied individuals at 84 percent), anxiety (94 percent) and depression, which affects the victim and the people who care about him or her.

 

Other health consequences include loss of concentration, panic attacks, feelings of paranoia, recurrent nightmares, suicidal thoughts and thoughts about being violent to others.

 

Can workplace bullying be resolved before it becomes problematic?

Namie says there are three distinct steps to take but that it's "easy to say, incredibly hard to do." Namie outlines three steps to potentially alleviate workplace bullying:

 

1. Name it

"Naming it is powerful, and it's the first step to making it legitimate so you don't blame yourself. Call it bullying, call it psychological harassment."

 

2. Take time off

"Get time off from work, and while you're off … check your legal options, check your health and start building the case [and] gather some data."

 

3. Expose the bully

"Go bully-busting. You've got to go as high up as you can, not HR. And make the business case that the bully is too expensive to keep. And you've got to show the turnover and all the other incidental things the bully causes in terms of disruption, absenteeism, [and] loss of productivity, and if that company doesn't want to listen to you, you get out for your health's sake."

 

Sadly, 77 percent of victims either leave or lose their jobs. "A lot of [the bullies] are just soccer moms. [Some] 58 percent of all the bullies are women. They're great people but they're situational bullies. They just transform themselves in the workplace and get hyper-aggressive," Namie says. "It gets rewarded. It gets them promoted. And that's why I think women are as likely to be bullies as men. They just simply read the cues."

 

So when it comes down to your health and the strength of family ties and friendships, weigh your options as to what can be the best solution for you. Leaving a negative work situation today may mean a positive future with less stress and other health complications. It's your call!

 

One Latina's Story

Although this woman would like to remain anonymous, her powerful story shows that the Workplace Bullying Institute findings are accurate. She says:

 

I was hired as an administrative assistant for a very prestigious center at a very prestigious university. I noticed from the start of my new job that my boss was not going to be the easiest person to work for. He belittled his staff in front of everyone. He took credit for the work that his staff did. He had very noticeable unethical practices in the workplace. And he did not respect the fact that I had recently lost my mother to heart disease and was very distraught over it. Basically, he just said, "Those things happen." Really?

 

I remember an incident when he requested that I arrange international travel for him. I made the arrangements and did not confirm the flight without his approval. When he was due to return to the United States, he called and asked why I booked the return flight on the date that it was scheduled--at which time I reminded him that he approved the flight. When he returned, he was in a very hostile mood with me. He called me in his office and closed the door to his office and would not let me leave until he finished screaming at me about the flight. I was floored, to say the least.

 

This is just one example of the mannerisms he displayed all the time. When I would leave work, I would be emotionally and physically drained. The best thing I could do was stay alone and not bother anyone with my work issues. During my sleep, I would awaken to my own screams. I always felt like my heart was beating way too fast. Every morning, when I would wake up, my stomach would turn into knots and I would feel very anxious, because I knew I had no choice at that time. I had to go to work. But I did not want to have to face my boss. He made my days and nights miserable.

 

The sad thing about this whole situation is that I would inform the people that I thought could help me and they wouldn't. His position in the company was far more important than mine. 

Readers' Comments

Your opinions and thoughts...
Posted Thursday Nov 20, 2008 by Guest;

 I recently attended a seminar at a Diversity conference which addressed bullying in the workplace.  The speaker was a lawyer who handled "bullying" cases and the financial impact it has on a company.  I was really impressed and found (in my optomistic view) especially now that the economy is the way it is that some of the reasons to keep a bully in the workplace may not hold true due to potential lawsuits and/or perceptions companies may face.  I don't agree with each tactic mentioned however, I do think there's more support for handling this differently than before.    

.
Posted Thursday Nov 20, 2008 by Guest;

 I recently went through bullying at the workplace by my female manager.  The manager twisted information so many times with the result of my looking bad.  I had always received 4/5s on my annual reviews (5 is the highest) and been with the company over 26 years.  The manager tried to put me on a 6-month plan to fire me -- based on her lies and skewing information.  I ended up taking a 5 month leave of absence.  I couldn't take the stress anymore - panic attacks, inability to sleep, health issues. I provided the HR person 35 pages of documentation to prove that I didn't have a negative attitude and that I had not "disobey" management directions.  I included date, times, emails.... I ended up in a different position (thank goodness).  I am still dealing with the aftermath of the whole situation and am pursuing legal options to have the bully exposed and be held liable for her inappropriate actions, including being allowed to place a performance review that is clearly wrong into my personnel file.
I think these bullies have low self-esteem.  And, of course, they are rewarded for their bad behavior.  Their bosses only see the good and are not exposed to their bully-type behavior.

.
Posted Friday Nov 21, 2008 by Guest;

 I am an African American female. I had a boss who used to treat me and other women the same way. In early 2000, there was a computer virus going around called "Love Virus" or something along those lines. If you got the virus it would attach to everyone on your email address, and send them the virus. My boss had me check his email every day. One day I told him it looks like we got that Email Virus from one of your colleagues, and I am not going to open. He yelled at me and said "OPEN IT, he wouldn't send me a virus! I did and the virus started taking over all our computers on the network system. I had to call a computer company to try to save/retrieve as much as data as possible, and of course with a big cost to the company. My boss told me, he told his "Banker Son", we got that virus, and his son replied "which nutcase in the office opened the email? He said son, "that nutcase was me. I demanded that my Assistant open the email. He apologized to me regarding that incident. I had a quote on my desk. "Every Human Being wants to be treated with love, respect and integrity." He said if you feel that I haven't treated you with respect. I am sorry.

I was on a contract, and when he offered me the job. I didn't take it. I talked with my husband about it. I felt that that was not a healthy environment to work in. Sometimes I would get sick to my stomach, and would wake up in the middle of the night. My advice to you is find another job; just don't let him know you're searching for something better.

.
Posted Sunday Nov 23, 2008 by Guest;

 I am a School Board Memeber and we were at conferences here in Chicago and we went to the conference on Bullying in Schools and i went on line to check for info on Bullying and when i checked my e-mail I noticed the one from you about Bullying in the workplace and it made me realize that I've heard some teachers are this way in our school and then realized, how can we teach the teachers to teach our children if it's happening in our school with Teachers too. Thanks for sending me this article, I will certainly forward to our Superintendent.

.
Posted Tuesday Nov 25, 2008 by Guest;

 

I have also been bullied by managers for many years; I've always managed to confront the issue as a means of protecting myself.  I've chosen my battles carefully, and sometimes had to walk away being the better person.  I've been faced with it again in my workplace just recently; at this point I am "FED UP". I am not quiet sure what actions to take at this time; I am still thinking about it.
The bottom line for me is, we can all complain about being mistreated by bad managers and continue to deal with them as best we know how (most time by ducking and dodging in the office, or taking days off work).  Or we can continue to tolerate the abuse, and allow the situation to deal with us from one job to another.  My question to Diversity Inc. is; what can we, the collective group whose lives that are negatively impacted by the cowardness of workplace bullies, do to make it known and exposed for the stench it is; while keeping our jobs, self esteem, and most of all our sanity?  
Is there such a group as "Tied of Being Bullied Anonymous"?  It would be interesting to form a coalition for the purpose of bringing this issue to the forefront and making it as illegal as sexual harassment, or any other violation against a person.  If anyone knows of such group please let me know I'd be interested in becoming a part of it.  I have many nightmarish stories to share.

.
Posted Wednesday Nov 26, 2008 by Guest;

 I am a recent victim of a workplace bully.  Due to her influence on our organization's new Director, my dream job was taken from me, I was demoted, my security clearance was reduced and my salary was reduced over $10k.  The humiliation and destruction of my character and spirit well never be repaired. My health has deteriorated and I am on various medications. I tried for a year to find another comparable position with no luck. My advice to anyone who finds themselves a bully victim (especially, if you are a minority) is to run as fast as you can to get out. Even if you have evidence of the cruelty, go to EEOC and win, you are blacklisted forever.  

.
Posted Thursday Nov 27, 2008 by Guest;

 I had several instances of bullying which went unanswered. I am naturalized US citizen originally from Ukraine. Once I was working in Japan for a language school and the supervisor - an American guy turned bad on me calling me a "Russian" and saying bad things about me. Eventually he did everything to oust me from my job there. I left in the end. I did complain but it was not taken seriously by anyone- like it was a joke or something. You see, I was not black,so I guess I couldbe bullied.There was a blackguy working for the same school and he was treated very well.
At my other job in California, my coworker found out I was foreign born and started giving me a hardtime. Calling me a foreigner an giving me dirty looks. Once he even shouted- GET OUT! ( ofthe US that is). When I protested that I was a US citizen like him, he chuckled- "I mean a foreigner- not born here". Eventually I left the place.
On other jobs I was told that if "I was not born in the US, I was not a full blooded US citizen".
Some interviews ended sadly as peoplewould smirk and escort me tothe door when they had found out I could speak Russian as anative tongue. I thoughtit would be an advantage, but itturnedout to be a liability. I had to remove it from my resume.
You do not haveto be a visible minority to be bullied. Naturalized US citizens are often treated like non-citizens.
In teh American culture people never ask others about citizenship- only "where are you from?" Another strange quirk in the US culture that makes it hard to assimilate.

.
Posted Thursday Feb 12, 2009 by Guest;

To those who find themselves bullied at work... you are not alone.

I just lost my job to a group of bullies. It is not the first time, and won't be the last. I make a good target for bullies because I am an honest, intelligent, hard-working person with an outstanding work ethic. I make a strong person for assault because bullies by nature are creatures haunted by their own inadequacy.

People who out-perform in the work-force and have a strong sense of integrity are usually the most vulnerable to bullies.

I feel your pain literally, but put your energy into getting the workplace bullying law passed in the US.

There is help on the website for the Workplace Bullying Institute.

Although they can't personally help, there is some great information about what to do...along with making you feel better knowing that this happens to so many and that there are people out there who understand and have been through this as well.

Don't give up. Get involved. We can complain and cry all we want, but until this we have a law in place, millions more will continue to be bullied. Until then, check out the books available that were and are a big help to me...Psychological Warfare at Work (Spindel), and The Bully at Work (Namie). They will do a world of good!

Believe me, I've been through it all! It only does so much to say I understand. We need to get together and get this into law!

.
Posted Thursday Mar 5, 2009 by Guest;

 I suffered from a bully for an excruciatingly long time, because I could not get my immediate supervisor to take the problem seriously.  She regarded it not as bullying, but as a personality conflict, and faulted me for not being able to get along with the bully.  I finally got relief when the big boss saw me crying one morning and made the mistake of asking me how I was doing.

.
Posted Monday Mar 23, 2009 by Guest;

I was a victim of bullying for an entire year. Sad it was a female boss who would do anything to get ahead and promoted! I am a minority female as she was, but she was sooooo competitive and had a nasty attitude. Well, as she would approach my desk we would get into disputes about how she spoke to me and I even grieved her. The company union I belonged to was a waste of time at that point and no help, the situation only got worse. I even documented every incident in my daily journal I kept at work. No help, upper management only was in her favor whenever I spoke to them about these continued issues. A coworker suggested I get a mini tape recorder and keep it in my desk or pocket all times at work. This would be helpful if I was to decide to have evidence with the EEOC or file my own harrassment lawsuit. Great idea! I did it a few times as she stood by my desk to approach me in her horrible manner. However, when I was ready to build my case she got laid off.

This was almost a year of stress I dealt with and the only people who understood were my coworkers. Management only cared that she made numbers and didn't care how she mistreated employees, how sad. After seven long years there, the first six were fine until I worked under her, I decided to take a severance buyout package and run the hell out of there! Not the environment for me! I was developing anxiety and depression as a result of daily attacks from the manager. It would only get worse if I stayed and continued to work under more deviant management. I just hated and resented my job, this was my sign to leave and move forward.

Just remember to keep a daily journal at work and if necessary a track of email correspondence and even a mini tape recorder! If it gets too serious you can always take time off to see a mental health expert(psychiatrist) who will give you adequate time off from work, due to stress. Use that time to look for other employment.

.
Posted Wednesday Jun 3, 2009 by Guest;
I am a very hard worker, very diligent, and I have very good leadership skills, and in groups most people look to me for direction. I also have a wide and strong reputation for integrity and ethical behavior, for going above and beyond to serve the community and organizations for which I work. I had a horrible experience in which I was bullied by the Executive Director of an organization who was also my direct supervisor. She is a white Jewish woman who spoke about her life and ethnicity as if she couldn't be racist because of it. But most people of color in community groups did not trust her because of her disrespectful behavior towards them. She was a former lawyer, so she knew very well how to get people to do what she wanted.When writing the organization's newsletter, her writing would frequently on several occasions she blamed people of color for various things, including being the targets of racism. When it was brought to her attention, she became very defensive. It took staff intervention (mine) and Board intervention to change the tone of her writing.Once, she asked me to find an IT person for our organization. As instructed, I did a wide search, put out a job call, collected resumes, scheduled interviews, called references, and did all the due diligence so that the ED could make her selection. The person that the ED hired was someone that I had never met before and was a woman of color but of a different ethnicity than mine (I'm African-American, the IT person was Asian-American). A few weeks later she made a snide remark about "hiring all your friends," while she had provided a job to the spouse of a white woman in the organization! There were more and more incidents like this, the snide and cruel remarks continued. At one point the ED asked me for a file that she needed and said that it was on my desk. I let her know that she had discussed the file with me but had not left it on my desk. (My desk is always very neat and organized and so it is very easy for me to know if there is something that doesn't belong there.) She loudly insisted that I had the file, to the point where she was yelling. I calmly let her know that I didn't have the file, and I even sat down to go through all of the files to show her that I didn't have the file. After yelling more she stomped off and went into her office. I could hear her slamming drawers and cabinet doors, dropping things, tearing through other things and making all sorts of noise. Ten minutes later she left her office (huffing and her hair askew) with the file in her hand. She then slammed it on my desk and stomped off. She would ask me to do things or give me permission to do things and then forget that she had done so. It got to the point where she accused me of being unethical or lacking integrity because she said that I did things without her permission. The reality was that she forgot that I did what she had asked me to do! It was one of the most stressful experiences of my life. I went to the Board of Directors for help, but they were her friends.It left me shaken, prone to crying jags, and depressed for months. I contemplated legal action (and had tons of documentation of everything that had happened) but was so exhausted by her bullying that I didn't want to fight her anymore. In the end I decided to just be gracious. That was what saved me, just like when I remained calm as she yelled about the file she couldn't find, being gracious in the face of her bullying made it clear to others what she was doing. Since then, some of the Board has apologized to me for her behavior and not doing anything about it, and thanked me for not suing them. I could care less, I left to find a job that is perfect for me, in an organizations run by people of color for people of color, where my hard work, diligence, leadership and vision are honored. This new organization is so successful, and trusted by people of color in our community, that we completely outshine the work of my former employer. Now I can be in public spaces with the ED of the old organization, and my publicly acknowledged for my integrity and ethical behavior. It puts all of her lies to shame..
Posted Monday Aug 17, 2009 by Guest;
I have a co-worker who I have been sitting next to for a year now and on my team. We don't even speak. Since she has been there I have tried to be friendly, but for some reason our personalities just don't click. Fellow Co-workers have called me crazy because I don't gossip or tell my business. I pretty much go in do my job and leave. I also seem to get along better with whites then I do with my own people (I am black). I actually like my job but because of being called crazy on a daily basis it is starting to effect my life. I can't tell management about this mainly because they agree with my co-workers. Does anyone have a solution without me getting another job. .

Comment on this article   
Name:
E-mail Address:
Comments:*


Career Search


Quick Search Advanced Search