This Web Accessibility icon serves as a link to download eSSENTIAL Accessibility assistive technology software for individuals with physical disabilities.

FEATURES











'Is Obama Victory for Blacks or for Everyone?' Readers' Comments
Compiled by the DiversityInc staff - Nov 18, 2008
Photo Comments have continued to pour in for "Is Obama Victory for Blacks or for Everyone?" Here is an update of what readers had to say. 

The views expressed in the Readers' Comments section are solely those of the writers and do not reflect the opinion of DiversityInc or its partners. DiversityInc reserves the right to not publish reader comments that are libelous, defamatory, obscene, pornographic, abusive, harassing, threatening, unlawful or promotes or encourages illegal activity. Further, the company reserves the right to delete, move or edit any content that it may determine, in its sole discretion, is otherwise unacceptable.

Your opinions and thoughts...
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

Thank you....I am a 40 year old, white woman, and I voted for Obama. I liked what he had to say, period. However, the following day, I felt left out. And, since folks want to label him, why is he considered African American, and not bi-racial? Anyway, the next 4 years should be interesting.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

I am 38 and white I voted for Barack Obama. I consider him to be bi-racial. But most importantly, I consider him my new president. I look forward to seeing him in the white house. In fact, he went there today I just saw. Great sight!

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

I feel I need to answer Leslie Orr' question: Why is Obama labeled African American and not bi-racial? To answer your question from a technical viewpoint, Obama is a true or real "AFRICAN AMERICAN" because his father is African and his mother is American. Now getting back on point, for years, society has defined the black race as "one drop/ounce of black blood" makes the child black. Thus, Obama's father is black, which makes him black (defined by society). Unfortunately, this has come back to smack White America because Obama did make history and he will go down in our American History as the "first Black President."

I am truly sorry that other races felt left out. However, one must understand that this is a great day for Blacks...especially black little boys. For years our children have been told that they could be anything but a president. And now, PRESIDENT-ELECT Obama has changed that "little white LIE."

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

In the comments above, it was aksed why is he considered African American, and not bi-racial. Race is not various colors or nationalities. For mankind, there is but one race: the human race. To be bi-racial would mean that one is part human and part something else, like cat. Why is Obama not considered a man, with the emphasis weighing of the many great qualities that make him such a great man? He has never come across as someone who is going to favor and serve one group of people. Why should there be any descriptions that would suggest such a thing?

I came into the office November 5th to a very hostile atmosphere--silence, pursed lips, etc. It's like I've been blamed for Obama's victory just because I'm a person of color--yet they don't know for whom I voted. Someone (a stranger) said to my cousin, "I guess you're happy." She replied, "Well, I guess you're happy, too!" She was judged by the color of her skin and spoken to as if her side won. The whole country has a new president-elect. Yet there is still a great divide in many minds and for what, is beyond me.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

I think his election is a victory for everyone in a number of ways.

1. He was the best candidate to lead our troubled nation and repair our standing globally.

2. This shows the world we as a people can select a leader based on qualifications regardless of race.

3. Because of item 2, we lead by example for other nations who may be narrow-minded thereby opening doors for them.

4. Hopefully, it will show corporate America the capacity non-caucasions can have in making them successful.

5. Maybe, just maybe, his success will be able to change the thinking of at least some of the bigoted Americans who dismiss the value of people who do not look like them.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

Obama won because we all voted for him, white, black, whatever. He won because of his ideas, and the wish to change things. We all just have to realize that it will take a long time to undue what has been done in the past. I am a white voter who voted for him and I know many more. For that matter, I know some black voters who didn't, so I do not think this can be classified as a primary black vote. My uncle is a die hard Democrat, and an ex Minnesota State Democratic Senator, and he voted for him as well, as did many of my other family members.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

Those are my thoughts exactly. I was also congradulated by my girlfriend who happens to be Puerto Rican.I was taken back when she did this as if it was only a victory for blacks.I explained to her that it was a victory for all people not just blacks and that she should be just as proud. After a lenthy discussion Iwas able to get through to her.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

I felt and still feel that Obama's victory is my victory regardless of the fact that my skin is white. This was the first President that I ever voted for because he exemplifies what I want a President to be. Until Obama, I had not seen a ticket that made me feel enfranchised. Though he will always be memorialised as the first Black President, I truly believe he will also be memorialised for being one of the greatest Presidents during one of the most difficult times in our Nation's history.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

Of course Obama won because he's the better candidate. But the reason his race is being emphasized so much is because of the fact that no one thought america as a whole, and white america in particular, was ready for a non-white president. This is a victory for american democracy.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

Leslie, You and many of my white college students have asked me the same question over the past week. My response has been, "Well, at the end of the day, that is how President elect Obama identifies himself-as an African American."

.
Posted Tuesday Nov 18, 2008 by Guest;

 

I voted for Barak Obama because he
is liberal, not for any other reason

.
Posted Tuesday Nov 11, 2008 by Guest;

I'm a 61 year old white woman and also a veteran of the anti-war movement and civil rights struggles of the 1960's. The election of this brilliant and humane individual to the presidency is such a huge and expansive victory for all human beings of good will that there is plenty of reason for rejoicing all around for a multitude of reasons. And one of the important reasons, looking back at the history that I have witnessed and in a small way been a part of, is that the dream Martin Luther King spoke of 45 years ago has in some measure been realized in our time. The fact that this is a special triumph for African Americans does not diminish in any way what a truly wonderful victory this is and promises to be for America and possibly the world.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

I have no problem focusing on race it is a reality one should not to apologize for...Yes I am Black and proud of this moment to be pc now and pretend elsewise is a fiction ..

I find those who seek to discount the reality of Race in Obama's victory do a disservice to reality and the truth...

One can be both Black and American and proud both ways..

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

This was a win for America, not merely African Americans: America made a choice: courage vs. fear; the many vs. the few; the planet vs. moneyed interests; inclusion vs. exclusion; the Constitution vs. tyranny; intelligence vs. ignorance; the world of nations vs. isolationism; character vs. color. Obama is the best of all of us: white and black, idealist and pragmatist, youth and maturity. America won Tuesday night.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

I am so glad to read this, I was thinking and saying the exact same sentiment. I think everyone should be proud that a majority of the nation listened to what was being said by both candidates and were able to make an informed, intellegant decision as individuals. After all isn't that what freedom of choice is. duh!!!

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

I agree 100% with the author's view. Whether intentional or not, the media managed to marginalize the importance of Barack Obama's victory by making it all about race. President-elect Obama is the right person at the right time to lead our country to the next level. He is NOT and will not be a Black President...he is and will be a visionary and talented President who happens to be Black.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

I agree with the author. By classifying this racially we miss so many valuable points. Obama is a strong man whose approach to inclusiveness is what many Americans have embraced. He calls on us all to be responsible and take part in the recovery of America. That recovery is not only the economy, it is also our reputatuion through-out the world. I also feel I have been disserved by the classification assigned to me, where being a middle-aged white female, my vote "surely" went to McCain. How outrageuos! Obama is a truly effective diplomat and I look forward to his leadership.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

Good day/evening, while reading through my e-mails I came across this e-mail and realize that he is the better person for the job. The question should be, all these years of being ran into the ground by the republicans, hey why not a new and fresh look in the white house. Who knows, he may make the difference needed to get this country going in the right direction.

Thank you for reading my comments.

Sincerely,

Wayne

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

Change like we've never known before...it's full of hope and awe and of things only imagined before. At a time when we are maybe even closer to a second more devestating depression than we may realize and in the midst two endless wars. We have finally grown tried enough of the old and fearful tales of our white fathers, the same fathers and leaders paralyzed by their own fear and disinterest of people not like themselves, these priviledged and disconnected leaders of our now recent past. Mr. Obama winning the election renewed my faith in what it means to me to be an American, to be able to come together as a people united, not divided. Thank God for Barack Obama, and for the millions of people who stood up and peacefully changed our nation's course, one people regardless of race, color, gender, religious preference, or national origin. Diversity? Yes! we need it now more than ever...as we look to our new leader with hope and an understanding that there is much work to be done.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

I couldn't agree with you more, Daryl! After this historic election this past Tuesday, I was beaming for the remainder of the week. I was a huge supporter of President-Elect Obama long before he was really known in the mainstream. I voted for him because his values were aligned with mine. Black or white, I would have supported him. I think his victory is not just for blacks, but for all Americans, even white folks like myself. I am sure there are many Americans who feel the same way. To discount his victory as simply a success for blacks, and not the entire country, discredits the votes of so many sensible Americans that saw President-Elect Obama as the best choice.

I was intrigued by a story NBC Nightly News ran. They noted that, if you segment out each voter category individually, i.e. young voters, white voters, black voters, latinos, over 65, etc, Barack Obama would have lost a couple of different states with each segment out of the mix, but he STILL would have one the election. No one segment helped push him over the top! This is the real story about just how far we have come as a county. I hope that this is only the beginning of a beautiful shift toward becoming a more inclusive and accepting nation.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

I was 21 in 1969 and have voted in every presidential election since then. I find it very interesting that no one has ever asked the question "Is this candidate a victory only for whites?" Mr. Obama has made it quite clear that he is President of the United States of America, not for a portion of its citizens. I feel we are spending far more time and energy on this topic than necessary. Just think if this same amount of concern was placed on the economy, two wars and education; we would be a lot further ahead. Get over the race aspect, it's not that serious.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

Barack Obama was elected President running on a platform that emphasized the irrelevance of "Red" and "Blue" states vs. the UNITED States of America. The MSM focused on the racial aspects of the victory because race/racism/ racial identity is still the "elephant" in our nation's living room. We (of all races) have yet to develop the maturity and language needed to have a meaningful dialogue on the subject.

Thus, while we (rightly in my view) castigated McCain/Palin for not dealing with the issues, the discussion continued about Obama's Blackness, or lack of it, or degree of it, or percentage of it!

Even Blacks who know that in America "one drop makes you whole" got involved in the discussion. Whites talked about Obama being "half white" while knowing that, in America, a White woman can give birth to a Black child, but a Black woman could never give birth to a White child.

Issues of race/racism/ racial identity are alive and well and living in America. That Barack Obama's election my well lead to a dialogue that could begin to put those issues behind us is "significant".

That Barack Obama applied techniques to the campaign process here-to-fore used only by community organizers, exploited the internet in his campaign better than anyone ever, basically rewrote the calculus on campaign financing, ran in the primary against a candidate seemingly poised for coronation, ran against candidates in the general election who raised questions about his experience/religion/patriotism/connection to terrorism/birth place, etc, and yet as a Democrat won 51% of the vote IS the point!

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

Obama focused on the issues of the people--all the people--of the United States. Obama never made the presidential race a 'racial' issue; it was politics. Nothing more, nothing less. That may be why he was elected. Why is the media and non-supporters making it a racial issue?

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

Hi Leslie,

You shouldn't feel left out because of the extensive, an justifiable celebration, by African Americans. The celebration was about YOU! African Americans were celebrating that fact that white americans, like you, listened to what Barack had to SAY, and HOW he said it, rather than how he looked. I too, congratulate and celebrate you. Also, Barack is "black". Statistically, there are very few African Americans who have no white or other ethnicity in their make-up. So what difference does the % make? Isn't the thought of that even more ridiculous than the label ("black" or "white")itself? We are black because you can SEE it in us. That is the bond that we share, our color. It's not a definition that African Americans created, it was white americans that created it. We don't abandon it when one of us does well,...because we certainly cannot when one of us doesn't.

.
Posted Tuesday Nov 11, 2008 by Guest;

As, an African American I am more proud of the fact that some people in America can look beyond the color of a person's skin color, and look at the quality of their character. I see progress, but in the South, I feel we still have a ways to go. I am a christian, and I am around people from different ethnic groups, which includes Whites. This time around, sorry to say I actually witnessed racism coming from my White christian friends. My friends said they were against Obama because of their values/beliefs and being conservative, but does those values have to include racism? I read in the bible that having respectful persons is a sin. I think some of them need to read the bible more closely, it says "to love thy neighbor as yourself," not love your neighbor because he has the same skin color.

.
Posted Monday Nov 10, 2008 by Guest;

Of course Obama won because he's the better candidate. But the reason his race is being emphasized so much is because of the fact that no one thought america as a whole, and white america in particular, was ready for a non-white president. This is a victory for american democracy.

.
Posted Wednesday Nov 12, 2008 by Guest;
This question need not be answered because the election was for all who voted for Barack. As a Black man, age 59 I can say over the course of my voting career I've cast my vote for 99 % white candidates. Now why are we being asked if voting for a Black President important to black people? When I see whites cheering and blacks tearing, what does that tell you about the human spirit.  .
Posted Wednesday Nov 12, 2008 by Guest;
Unfortunately this country is obsessed with race, sex and other factors that tear away at unity. With this new election we as a nation need to focus on matters that are important to all people regardless of their race or sex.   Obama's victory is most certainly due to his magnificant campaign people who saw beyond color and presented an intelligent eloquent man. He is a man who the American people  recognized as having unlimited potential and qualities to run this nation. Those voters who are ready for a change selected the candidate who would bring about that change.
.
Posted Wednesday Nov 12, 2008 by Guest;
The election of Barack Obama as President of the USA should be a very proud moment for all Americans because of the historical significance it has for this country. This comes as close as any recent President in unifying Blacks, Whites, and Browns, the East, West, North and even the South. I also see no problem in portraying him as African-American, even though some say he is Bi-Racial, his self description is AA. Most AA's are mixed, so he is no exception, for that.  He is exceptional because of his character and abilities!.
Posted Tuesday Nov 11, 2008 by Guest;
President Obama's victory was for all people. But we still have to realize and acknowledge that it's a very proud moment for African Americans. Just as the Irish felt a sense of pride when JFK was elected into the white house. Just because you have racial  pride, doesn't make it a bad thing, it's all in how you interprete it. We are in a good place right now, a place of hope, a place of willingness to strive for something different as a people, all people. Let African Americans have their inspiration, it's been a long time coming. It doesn't take away from any one group.
.
Posted Tuesday Nov 11, 2008 by Guest;
As an african american i'm proud that he won , but even more proud that regardless of color he had the  best educational credentials and instead of have another college graduate at the bottom of thier graduating class we now have a man that was at the top of his class...because we all know that if he ran with McCains and Bush's class standings he would have never been elected and even more so if he had a unwed teenage daughter ...so i applaud intelligence  
.
Posted Tuesday Nov 11, 2008 by Guest;
Thank you for a timely and thoughtful article.  Your point is well made.  Many well meaning people and organizations missed the point.  At no point did he campaign as a candidate for Black people or minorities.  He campaigned as an individual who wants to be president of ALL people in the United State of America.
.
Posted Tuesday Nov 11, 2008 by Guest;
I'm a white woman, and I'm excited that our next POTUS will be a Democrat.

.
Posted Wednesday Nov 12, 2008 by Guest;
As a child of the "Jim Crow Era" and the "Seperate But Equal Doctrine" also educated in the discipline of Political Science and Social Science let me first say, "my undergraduate prof at FSU must re-write her lecture for the course The U.S.Presidency"  a decade a go the lecture "a Black male because of the pool of applicants, race, and America's history of race based politics" we would never see such a historical event. Obama campaign was almost flawless to the point that you can't help but believe he's the one to unite Americans in-to what we have the ability to become as a nation state.    
.
Posted Tuesday Nov 11, 2008 by Guest;
I am a 62 year old African American and I am reading with interest how some readers insist on labeling Barack as being bi-racial as opposed to being African American. There seems to be some difference in being bi-racial as if that is "`better" than being Black.I find this a bit irritating and wonder what some of these people are implying. .
Posted Wednesday Nov 12, 2008 by Guest;

 My parents came from Puerto Rico in the 1930s, when Hispanics were expected to lose their accent and blend in as white or black according to appearances. When my father was jailed in Albany, Georgia for his efforts in the civil rights movement, I wonder if he thought his day would come in his life time.
I'm excited about Barack Obama's victory. Nevertheless, I'm concerned about Mr. Obama's campaign which seemed to take the Black Community for granted. I hope his administration does not  leave African Amercians in the same or worse place as white administrations, based on the assertion that racial barriers have been "overcome."

.
Posted Wednesday Nov 12, 2008 by Guest;

 I don't like to think of it as a victory for blacks, because I think it is a form of racism to attribute every success a black person makes to the the black race. When a white  person succeeds at something it is never attributed to their race, it is attributed to mankind.
I think white-majority-America voting in a black president is a step for mankind towards greater equality and acceptance of people for who they and what they are capable of instead of te colour of their skin.

 
.
Posted Wednesday Nov 12, 2008 by Guest;

 I know everyone wants to say that President-Elect Obama is bi-racial or for all Americans. And he is for all Americans. However, there was a time when an American could have one drop of Black blood and he would be considered Black and the same can be said of Jewish people.  The problem is now everyone wants to discount the fact that President-Elect Obama is an African-American.  When you apply for a job there is no check mark for "Bi-racial."  You may check as many checks as you want, but once you choose Black/African-American or any of the other minority checks you are by default a minority.  I'm tired of everyone trying to justify why they chose an African-American by saying that he is bi-racial.  "Bi-racial" is not a race.  He is the best candidate for the job, but at the end of the day he is a member of the Congressional "Black" Caucus not the Congressional "Bi-Racial" Caucus.

 
.
Posted Thursday Nov 13, 2008 by Guest;

 I did not vote for Barack because he was black.  I voted because he was well spoken and hit a lot of key areas of concern. I'm thrilled that one more barrier has been broken.  We are moving in the right direction.
While I am not black, my ancestors suffered discrimination too.  It's not a pleasant thing and moving forward is the best medicine.
I haven't watched our president speak in 8 years.  I'm looking forward to resuming my desire.  He has a mess to clean up, but I have great confidence in his skills.  It's who he surrounds himself with too and so far it's looking pretty promising.
PS:  I also see the love he has for his wife and daughters and that tells a lot about a person.
He's not a spoilled little rich boy that hasn't a clue on how people struggle to make ends meet.  Barack has had his own challenges in life and that builds character.

.
Posted Thursday Nov 13, 2008 by Guest;

 I did not campaign and vote for a black candidate. I campaigned and voted for the very best candidate who happened to be black. I believe that he is the one who will build bridges rather than walls.

.
Posted Thursday Nov 20, 2008 by Guest;

 I am 28 yrs of age and this election was my first time voting. I always use to say that my vote didn't count that this U.S.government would always put ion office who they wanted I still feel that way and I guess now they were finally tired of presidential candidates who didn't know what they were talking about.  I used to say the day i vote is the day we have a black president not thinking the day would come, even when I voted I still had this thought in the back of my mind that McCain might still win.  I was so shocked and surprised Obama won I cried. The first time I ever voted, followed politics, and even listened to a debate and I can honestly say now we hace the best man for the job regardless of his race, color, or ethnic status God bless him and his famliy. And I pray God is on his side.

.
Posted Thursday Nov 20, 2008 by Guest;

 Being a Black man, I would have voted for Obama if he was white. I am an Independent and have voted Republican before.

.
Posted Wednesday Nov 26, 2008 by Guest;

 The election of Barack Obama symbolizes so much that it is difficult for me to know where to begin. It is evident that he did not win because of his skin color. I think it symbolizes the strength, dedication and optimism for a man to reach his dream as well as a country becoming more diverse. Many years ago, a man or woman of his race would not have even been considered as a nominee. This is a sign that times have changed. This election speaks volumes to the world. It ties back to what many civil rights leaders have fought for and preached about -- do not judge a man by the 'color' of his skin but by the 'content' of his character (Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr.). It is evident that President Obama is more than qualified to lead our great country. He is well-educated, well-spoken, dedicated to his family, and sincerely concerned about all human beings lives. Even though he plans to improve life for 95% of the middle class, this does not mean that he is out to make life worse for the upper class. His plan is to add some balance to the equation. Someone earning below $250,000 as compared to someone earning multi-million dollars (especially with the poor economy) definitely needs more tax breaks, etc. At the rate the economy is going and with the stagnant job market, the middle class and lower class are beginning to merge into one lower class. I think Obama plan will equalize all classes. A person making multi-millions has a lot more cushion and room to adjust their standards of living than someone making $35,000-$75,000.

As far as education...it speaks for itself; the man is well-educated. The symbolization in this is that he is inspiring people both young and old to strive to educate themselves. He has proven that through his education and devotion, a man can accomplish anything (including becoming President of the USA). This is inspirational to all races and ages, but even more so for those who have been underprivileged or thought certain things were impossible because of their race.

As far as healthcare, everyone deserves treatment. Sometimes it is difficult for those who can afford healthcare and other necessities to see things from another's point of view (like those who are working hard or are unemployed for whatever reason and honestly cannot afford insurance coverage).

I could go on forever about this historical event, but I will wrap this up. I am a firm believer that one can reach his or her destination, though sometime the struggle or road to victory might require more effort than normal. The end result speaks for itself. We have a good man with good plans! Like Obama stated, he cannot save everyone and some of his decisions may not make everyone happy, but he will do his BEST. Based on his character, I truly believe he will be a man of his word. Honesty is very important. Change has come to the United States of America! Thank God for that. If he does a great job as planned, hopefully Americans of all races and political affiliations will give him the respect and props he deserves. 8 years of change (yes, I'm being optimistic) would be wonderful! The main thing to remember is that a man can only give his best. Along with success comes some failure.

I have my personal opinion about politics. In the past, I dreaded watching the debates and events that led up to the election because the debates and comments seemed to come across so negative. The candidates spent more time and money bashing each other rather than focusing on the worldly issues at hand. The main thing that Americans want and deserve to know is what a man or woman plans to do to help them improve their situation. Barack did a great job of staying focused on the world's issues and he was very positive and calm throughout the election. He won hands down a couple of months before the election date of 11.04.08

.
Posted Tuesday Dec 2, 2008 by Guest;

 I find this topic a little perplexing because I didn't view it as "either/or". I think the Obama victory is for everyone AND for African Americans. I voted for President-Elect Obama because I believe he is the right man for the job at this divinely appointed time in history. But I'm not going to deceive anyone, I was extremely and unapologetically proud that he is African-American. I cried election night because I thought of my grandmother and all those  before me (both Black & White people) who sacrificed so much so that we could get to this point. That should not be overlooked or forgotten. And I don't think that excludes anyone from the celebration. Black, White, Asian, Hispanic etc. can join in the enthusiasm of positive change that is about to take place in this nation.

.
Posted Wednesday Dec 17, 2008 by Guest;

 I just wanted to say that , no matter your affiliation, the one thing I am proud of this election, is that people got off their duff, and exercised the RIGHT TO VOTE, that so many sacrificed so much to gain for us as individuals, as women , as minorities! And to see the power and results of said action, first handed, for so many, for the first time, only strenghens our democracy....lets use that experience to CONTINUE TO BE PERSONALLY INVOLVED, in our nation, state, county, city, town's policies and government...WE THE PEOPLE....LEST WE FORGET, AND GIVE IT AWAY!!

Click here to read "Is Obama Victory for Blacks or for Everyone?"

 

 

.
Posted Friday May 1, 2009 by Guest;
It was a mistake to elect Mr. Obama. His Marxist/Socialist idealogy will wreck the U.S. He is really only a figurehead - Nancy Pelosi pulls his strings..

Comment on this article   
Name:
E-mail Address:
Comments:*


Career Search


Quick Search Advanced Search